Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts

Saturday, April 26, 2014

Boundaries Protect: Five Tactics for Setting Boundaries


“I can’t say, ‘No.’ I don’t want to make them mad at me!” This person is struggling with setting a boundary. The person doesn’t want to go along with someone’s request, but is more concerned with the other’s feelings than how agreeing to the request makes the person themselves feel. Now, it is good to be thoughtful and helpful and to care about others’ needs. The problem comes when an individual always compromises and ignores or subverts one’s own needs and feelings. The problem is being out of balance and skewed in favor of the other too much. People do have the right to care about themselves, to protect themselves.

Boundaries are the limits we put into place to protect ourselves from being harmed by others. They are rules which guide people such that they don’t harm each other. People with healthy boundaries respect the boundaries of other people, even if the other people do not know to enforce those boundaries themselves. Harm comes about in situations where people with poor boundaries interact. A common scenario is the combination of a person who doesn’t respect others’ boundaries taking advantage of someone who isn’t good at recognizing and enforcing their own boundaries. Some people care so little of others’ boundaries that they cross them even when they are clearly expressed, for example, a thief steals even with signs saying ‘Shoplifters will be prosecuted.’ The crossing of boundaries can happen on a continuum from simply, without malice, not recognizing that a boundary exists to quite knowingly pressing through boundaries.

Pia Mellody, in her book, “Facing Codependence,” gives an excellent explanation of the various combinations of intact and non-intact boundaries. She also explains how boundaries are learned. In general, we learn boundaries as children from our parents who both teach us and demonstrate by their own behavior, how we should be in this world. A child who grows up with parents with poor boundaries, for example, a child who is being sexually molested, is not taught appropriate boundaries, has its own inherent boundaries crossed by a more powerful adult, and doesn’t learn what appropriate boundaries are or even that they can have their own boundaries. This child grows up having difficulty even knowing how to gauge appropriate boundaries. People generally do grow up having learned boundaries, and vary in their abilities to enforce boundaries in different situations with different people. For example, a person may be very good at holding boundaries with acquaintances but doesn’t maintain boundaries and gives in easily to Mother’s demands.

Most of us struggle to sort out boundaries in complex situations. It is overly simplistic to think we can simply say, “No,” in any situation which makes us uncomfortable. For example, at work, people cannot simply refuse to do aspects of a job they don’t like doing. However, when job duties are compounded so much that they practically cannot be completed in the allotted time and this continues indefinitely such that it is causing burnout in the employee, this would be the time for the employee to recognize limits and boundaries and speak to the employer about making changes. (Labor laws exist to protect employees from abuse.) In personal relationships, people must compromise and take into account each other’s feelings and needs, but when does one person’s compromising become unhealthy self-deprivation or another’s lack of compromise become selfishness rather than healthy self-care.

There are five tactics which help in setting boundaries:

Recognize your own feelings. The first step in setting appropriate boundaries is honoring your own feelings. Do not deny or ignore any feelings. Some feelings have gained a bad reputation as being “bad” feelings or “weak” feelings. In fact, all feelings are guides and should be noticed. Feeling nervous or uncomfortable may be an instinct telling you something isn’t right. Anger and frustration can be signals that you need to enforce a boundary or ask for changes to be made. Sadness could mean you are not taking care of your own needs.

Know your preferences. Sometimes people do not enforce boundaries because they do not know their own opinion! When a person doesn’t know what they like or what they want, they open the door for others to do the choosing for them. If you can’t make a decision, someone else will make it for you. When you leave all of the choices and decisions up to someone else, over time, you lose yourself. Some find they “don’t even know who I am.” Notice your own likes and dislikes, have a favorite color, know what vegetables you like and don’t like, have an opinion on what movie to see.

Be reasonable, give yourself guidelines. Decide what you are willing to live with and when it is time to speak up. For example, you might choose to speak up when something has annoyed you at least three times. If it only happens once, you don’t say anything, you just tolerate it. If it happens repeatedly, three times in our example, you determine this is worth speaking up about and asking for change. Practice assertive communication. Or you might have values be your guidelines. You might decide that you will not live with someone who breaks your trust or who isn’t loyal. Know your own values.

Practice honesty. Be honest with yourself. Be honest with others. Many of us have been taught to lie in the practice of being polite. We have been taught it is polite to always appear happy. It is polite to not be a bother to others. When someone asks you how your day was, it is ok to reply, “Some good, some bad,” rather than the standard, non-informative, “It was fine.” Or we have learned to lie by omission. We do not want to burden others with our own experiences, so we don’t tell. But the reality is we are not having true, real relationships with others, if we do not share our own experience. We lose ourselves and our ability to have boundaries when we don’t express our honest experience.

Learn to say, “No.” Many people shudder in fear and trepidation at the thought of actually saying “No” to any request. But we become over-committed and then over-stressed when we are not able to set limits on our time and energy we have available to give to others. We harm ourselves, and others take advantage when we are not able to set a firm limit. Abusers are attracted to those who don’t recognize their own right to hold a limit. The December 2013 issue of Psychology Today magazine has an article by Judith Sills, PhD titled, “The Power of No.” She provides guidelines on how to begin the practice of effectively, kindly, assertively saying “No.”


Maintaining boundaries is a way to protect ourselves from interpersonal harm. It is also how we stay connected to our own identity. Boundaries help us to maintain the “self.” To be human is to be in relationship with other humans. Learning to have boundaries in relationships with other people contributes to healthier, more equal relationships for all involved.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Knowing, Protecting, and Expressing Identity

I think therefore I am - Descartes. But who am I? How do we know who we really are (identity) and how do we honor that unique person?

Without a sense of identity, people flounder. They can have difficulty in relationships with others and trouble maintaining stability in life. Poor sense of identity is an underlying cause of many maladaptive behaviors and much mental anguish.

Identity is a sense of one’s unique self which is separate from others and is in relation to others. It includes what we believe, our preferences, values, passions, unique talents and attributes, and the groups with which we associate.

Closely connected with identity is self-esteem which is an evaluation of one’s own worth.  It includes the amount of confidence in self based on experience and on successful achievement.

Our identity develops from our genetic composition and from the beliefs and values taught to us by caregivers. Then it is honed by our own experiences and assessments, is influenced by society and culture, and is adjusted in response to feedback from others and to our experience of outcomes.

We honor our unique identity by developing healthy boundaries (the limits we set) and by having an assertive approach to interpersonal interactions.

A couple of useful books on boundaries are: 
  1. Boundaries, Where You End and I Begin by Anne Katherine, and
  2. Facing Codependence by Pia Mellody.


An assertive approach to interacting with others serves to: express our true selves honestly, protects the self, gets one’s needs met, and allows one to have safety in relationship with others.


In my next post, I will discuss several styles of interpersonal interaction, including the assertive style.

Readers, do you have anything you would add, especially any references to good books on these topics?